
Romeo y Julieta 1875
Bully
Tasting
Romeo y Julieta 1875, a mild-to-medium Indonesian-wrapped blend, smooth and cedary.
Consensus: 90-94 Outstanding · box-worthy · 76% would smoke again (30 reviews)
Pairs with
Roasted cocoa and coffee notes simply double down — the classic after-dinner pairing.
Earthy, woody notes lock onto the malt's dry oak and heather without either side shouting.
Rye's own pepper meets the smoke's spice head-on — a deliberate, warming match.
Flavor signature
Reviews
Cigar press, enthusiast communities, and your own log — all in one place.
“Better with 6 more months.”85
Be the first to log a smoke and share it publicly.
Sign in to log a smoke, score it by thirds, and build your tasting history.
Score distribution
Cigars like this
Available at
Prices & stock are community-sourced snapshots (Jul 8, 2026) — check the retailer for live availability.
Specification